Last night, for the first time, I went to a comedy class - - a Manhattan Comedy School course for intermediate comics taught by veteran comedy writer Frank Santopadre.
I have always been skeptical of such classes. There's the expense, for one thing. As you all well know, spending money to study something that will probably never make you money is an unwise proposition.
I also felt like there was a certain stigma attached to comedy classes. I remember the first time I performed at Ha!, Exiene, the one-named gay comic who haunts that club, offered me the following critique: "Well, it's OBVIOUS you've taken a comedy class." He didn't mean it as a compliment. And he was wrong!
Of course, months later, the New Yorker magazine referred to Exiene in its comedy issue as "pear-shaped," "calculating," and "hard," so who's laughing now?
Anyway, comedy just seemed like one of those things you couldn't teach, like good taste or good sex. But then it occurred to me that there's no such thing as wasted education. So maybe I wouldn't learn how to be a better comic, but surely I'd learn SOMETHING.
And yeah, OK: I thought it might make for some good material.
So I went. And it was cool. Sort of.
There are about 12 students in the class, of various ages, shapes, sizes and genders. They include Colin, an unspeakably handsome 24-year-old recovering alcoholic from Long Island (on whose stunning looks nobody -- male or female -- could refrain from commenting); Tashi, a British, Jewish, self-described slut with a holocaust-survivor grandmother and an obsession with Prada shoes; Joe, a fraternal twin with A.D.D, and Kevin, a 38-year-old who's been married three times, once for just six days.
So it's basically like any other 12-step group.
I missed the first class last week, where the assignment had been to come back this week with three minutes of material you consider 'taboo'-- material you had previously been too afraid to do.
Since I had nothing new prepared, I decided I'd do my Chinese roommates bit. For those of you who haven't seen it, it's the true story of my experience living in an all-Chinese dormitory suite in grad school. It's a long bit, and definitely my edgiest. (Sample joke: "These roommates spoke no English, and they were very hostile toward me. Like they wouldn't even do my laundry.")
Not groundbreaking, but sort of taboo, no?
So before I even did the bit, I got up to the mic and I went, "So how 'bout Christopher Reeve dying?!"
Stunned silence.
It got worse from there. The whole bit begins with my saying, "Look, this story may be politically incorrect, but before you go getting all offended, keep in mind that I am (and here I count out five fingers) gay, Jewish, left-handed, from New Jersey... and (pinky finger here) I have a small penis."
Crickets. Beautiful Colin looked like he needed a stiff drink. Slutty Tashi glared at me like a neglected housecat.
By the time I got to the finale, ("But in the showers, compared to the other guys, my penis -- not so small!") I was literally covered in flop-sweat. Silently I returned to my seat.
"Well," said Frank, the instructor, "I love your energy. And I love your confidence. You literally seem to have no inhibitions."
(Translation: "You are inappropriate to the point of being insane.")
He continued: "But you set us up to find out all these great things about you -- that you're gay, Jewish, left-handed, have a small penis, etc -- and then you don't talk about any of them. Instead, you focus on making fun of these Chinese roommates." He approached the blackboard. "Can anyone come up with some words to describe the way Adam came across in his set?"
"Control freak!", yelled some anonymous person from the back row.
"Racist!", offered another.
"Asshole!", I cried, jumping on the bandwagon.
"Yes!", agreed Frank, writing "CONTROL FREAK RACIST ASSHOLE" on the board. "Now we need to actually SEE those things about you in your material."
"Well, yes," I said, wiping the sweat from my eyes, "but keep in mind I don't usually open with this bit. My other material does show more about me..."
"Don't get defensive," said Frank. "We're just saying you're wasting an opportunity to tell us about you. And frankly, someone with your obvious intelligence shouldn't have to resort to imitating the way Chinese people talk."
That loud splat sound was my brains hitting the back wall. So much for taboo.
The upside of this brutal drubbing is this: So hungry am I for approval from my peers and from authority figures that I have vowed to blow them away next time with the most brilliant three minutes of my life. I mean, I'm going to make them laugh until they pee, so help me. I'm going to become the teacher's pet and the envy of my classmates. Then they'll see who's funny!
Maybe not the healthiest motivation, but hey -- it got me through 17 years of school, didn't it?